Discussing your professional accomplishments — or your mistakes — isn’t always easy. That’s why many employees dread the annual performance review. After all, not only do you receive feedback from your manager, but you’re often asked to write a self-assessment as part of the process.
While it may feel awkward, writing your annual performance review is a valuable opportunity to showcase your achievements, reflect on areas for growth and set career goals for the year ahead.
Here’s everything you need to know about how to write your annual performance review.
What Is an Annual Performance Review?
An annual performance review is a designated time each year when an employee’s work performance is formally evaluated. While the review typically includes feedback from the employee’s direct manager, it often incorporates input from colleagues and other leaders as well. The goal is to take a comprehensive look at what the employee has accomplished over the past year, identify areas where they’ve excelled and address any challenges or opportunities for improvement.
But a performance review isn’t just about looking back — it’s also an opportunity to look ahead. This is the ideal time to discuss career goals, establish priorities for the year to come and align expectations with your manager. It’s also a natural moment to talk about potential promotions, raises or skill development. You might ask your manager what steps are needed to move to the next level, or what a realistic timeline might look like for career advancement.
Most performance review processes begin with a self-assessment: a written reflection submitted by the employee. This personal review sets the stage for a more in-depth, two-way conversation with your manager, where you’ll go over your accomplishments, growth areas and goals together. When approached thoughtfully, this process can be one of the most valuable tools for shaping your professional development and ensuring your work is aligned with your team and organization’s success.
What Are the Benefits of an Annual Performance Review?
Yes, an annual performance review can feel intimidating. You may receive some negative feedback, but keep in mind that even those words can be beneficial. Nobody is perfect and everyone has room to grow. Think of it as an opportunity for clarity: you can only improve if you know where you need to go and are open to advice.
Of course, positive feedback is a major benefit of the review process, as well. It’s motivating to have your hard work recognized and it reinforces that you’re on the right track. Acknowledgement from your manager can boost morale and help sustain your momentum throughout the year.
Beyond feedback, the annual review is also a key time for career development planning. It’s a chance to ask important questions. For example, what would it take to earn a promotion? How can you demonstrate readiness for the next step? Are there opportunities for a raise or expanded responsibilities? Use the review to set clear career goals, align expectations with your manager and define what success looks like in the year ahead.
What Are the Best Tips for Writing an Annual Performance Review?
Before having a conversation with your manager, however, you likely have to write your own self-assessment. To make the most of this opportunity — and to leave a strong impression on your manager — keep the following tips in mind:
Be as specific as possible. Highlight particular projects you worked on throughout the year and explain how you contributed to them. If you have hard numbers that demonstrate your accomplishments, use them. (For example, “My articles generated 100,000 page views per month” or “One hundred fifty clients signed with us after my presentation.”) Whenever possible, support your statements with concrete examples. This not only demonstrates the impact of your work but also shows that you’re approaching your self-assessment thoughtfully and seriously.
Focus on the positive — but don’t forget to acknowledge growth areas. It’s important to advocate for yourself and highlight the contributions you’ve made to your company or organization. At the same time, a thoughtful self-assessment includes areas for growth and acknowledges where you’ve faced challenges. The key is to frame them as learning opportunities that have contributed to your development.
Keep the language clear and professional. As with any written presentation, tone is key. While your self-review is personal in nature, it should remain professional in tone. Avoid overly casual language or unnecessary detail. Clear, concise writing is most effective. Before submitting, review your draft for spelling, grammar and flow. Strongly written communication is a valuable skill in most positions and your review is an opportunity to demonstrate it.
Look toward the future. A review may be about the past, but this is also the time to discuss the future. Detail your career goals, discuss how you can make that happen and leave space for your manager to help you figure out your timeline and next steps.
What Are Common Mistakes People Make While Writing an Annual Performance Review?
As you write your annual performance review, be mindful of common mistakes that can undermine your message or impact. Avoid the following pitfalls:
Being vague. General statements can weaken the impact of your successes. Clearly define your accomplishments by detailing specific projects, outcomes and metrics.
Using a combative tone. Responding to feedback with defensiveness can come across as unprofessional or that you don’t understand the challenges you faced. Instead, approach the review with openness and a willingness to grow.
Minimizing mistakes — or accomplishments. Similarly, don’t downplay your wins or pretend you’ve done everything perfectly. A balanced review shows that you can recognize both strengths and areas for improvement, which every manager values.
Overlooking your goals or job responsibilities. Make sure your review reflects your actual job duties and the goals you’ve been asked to achieve. If your examples don’t align with your role, it may raise concerns about your focus or priorities.
What Should You Expect After an Annual Performance Review?
After writing your self-assessment, proofreading it for any errors and submitting it, your manager will likely gather feedback from coworkers and peers to prepare for your annual performance review. During the review meeting, you’ll reflect on your achievements over the past year, discuss upcoming opportunities and explore potential raises or promotion paths. Once the review process is complete, you can shift your focus to pursuing your new goals.
While it may seem intimidating, the annual review period is meant to set you up for success in the workplace, giving you the opportunity to reflect on your accomplishments, identify areas for growth and collaborate with your manager to set clear goals for the year ahead.
Access more career advice from USC Online today.